This has worked out swimmingly so far.

However, his major league performance post-promotion has been underwhelming. After serving an 80‑game suspension in 2024, Marte struggled at the plate with a .210 average, managing just four home runs, 18 RBIs, and nine stolen bases across 229 at-bats. This slump extended into 2025 spring training, where he was optioned back to Triple‑A Louisville following an 0-for‑11 stretch with eight strikeouts and a low .150/.182/.400 slash line.

Marte’s struggles were more than just a personal downturn; they reflected the unpredictability that comes with prospect risk. Given his pedigree, there were legitimate worries that the Reds might later regret not trading him earlier while his stock was still high. Instead, his poor showing validates the front office’s cautious approach this past offseason.

This situation also alleviates pressure on Cincinnati’s infield depth. With players like Gavin Lux, Elly De La Cruz, and Jeimer Candelario also in the mix, Marte’s failure to stick in the majors means the Reds can rely on those who have recently shown more consistency—without worrying about losing a high-upside piece prematurely.

From a strategic standpoint, it’s a relief that the Reds have avoided what could’ve turned into a classic “trade regret” scenario. Trading Marte at peak value would have been tempting; his collapse, however painful, ultimately spares the front office that difficult decision.

Now, the Reds can reassess their long-term plan. Promising arms like Edwin Arroyo—another former trade acquisition—also dropped from the top-100 list and never quite took off. The organization may now focus on fostering internal talent or exploring other low-risk trade options.

All told, while Marte’s journey is a cautionary tale of hype and unmet expectations, it’s one that’s ended up benefiting the Reds by helping avoid a potentially regrettable move.