The Reds acquired 27-year-old utility-infielder Gavin Lux in early 2025, expecting him to contribute in multiple spots on the field. While versatility is a plus, Lux’s production for the season fell short of expectations: he slashed .269/.350/.374 with a 102 wRC+ for the year, rather than replicating his stronger finish in 2024.
Given his performance, the Reds now face a decision on whether to retain Lux — but a key factor tilting the scales is the emergence of Spencer Steer. According to one report, Steer’s versatility and readiness could allow the Reds to cover the same “super-utility” role that Lux occupies — thereby making Lux, with an estimated ~$5 million arbitration cost, a potential luxury they can shed.
Steer, who spent time at first base and DH in 2025 due to a shoulder issue, is viewed as capable of filling multiple positions (at least in theory) and thus could replace or duplicate Lux’s value at a lower cost. Thus, in the view of the article, Lux becomes “expendable” because the Reds believe they already have his replacement internally.
Beyond just cost, the Reds’ roster construction supports a “move on” scenario for Lux. With younger players ascending and depth increasing, the rationale is that investing $5 million in a super utility man who offers average bat/defense may not be the best use of resources. The organization appears willing to reallocate that money elsewhere.
That does not mean Lux has no value — his positional flexibility still matters — but the margins become tighter when you have internal options. The article suggests that the Reds may either non-tender him (letting him become a free agent) or shop him in trade this offseason rather than simply retaining him by default.
From Lux’s perspective it’s a delicate spot: under club control through 2027, but if the Reds choose not to view him as essential, he could shift to a new club where his role is more secure. Conversely, for the Reds, freeing up that slot and that money gives them more flexibility heading into the 2026 season.
In short: The Reds appear to believe they have built-in coverage for Lux’s role (via Spencer Steer), which in turn makes Lux’s retention less imperative. For him, the offseason may hinge on whether Cincinnati sees him as part of the core, or an asset they’re willing to move in favor of flexibility and cost-efficiency.
