Maple Leafs Miss Out on Potential Free-Agent Steal
The Toronto Maple Leafs have missed an opportunity to take a low-risk gamble on veteran forward Jeff Skinner, who has decided to continue his career in Europe rather than return to the NHL. Skinner signed a one-year contract with EHC Biel-Bienne in Switzerland, ending any possibility of Toronto bringing the longtime NHL scorer into its revamped lineup.
Skinner, 34, is no longer the consistent 30-goal scorer he was earlier in his career, but there was still a case for the Maple Leafs to take a chance on him. The Toronto native has extensive NHL experience and has demonstrated throughout his career that he can provide offense when given the right role and enough opportunities.
His most recent NHL seasons were not particularly productive, but his track record remains intriguing. Last season, Skinner recorded six goals and 13 points in 32 games with the San Jose Sharks while averaging a little more than 12 minutes per night. The season before that, he scored 16 goals and 29 points in 72 games with the Edmonton Oilers.
-ep.jpg)
Those numbers are a significant step down from the peak of his career. Just a few seasons ago, Skinner was one of the NHL’s most productive even-strength scorers. In 2022-23, he scored 35 goals and 82 points in 79 games with the Buffalo Sabres, following a 33-goal campaign the previous season.
That history is what makes his departure particularly interesting from Toronto’s perspective.
The Maple Leafs have undergone a significant roster transformation this summer under general manager John Chayka. Toronto has added several players to reshape its lineup and give new head coach Jim Hiller more options heading into the upcoming season.
Skinner could have been another intriguing piece.
Rather than expecting him to return to his former superstar level, Toronto could have used him in a sheltered third-line role or as an inexpensive depth scorer. The idea would have been to see whether a change of scenery and more favorable offensive deployment could help him rediscover some of his scoring touch.
The Leafs could also have benefited from his familiarity with the Toronto market. Skinner is a Toronto native, making a potential return home an appealing storyline. More importantly, the organization could have given him an opportunity to play alongside talented offensive players and receive favorable offensive-zone assignments.
The team’s revamped roster could potentially have provided the conditions for such a gamble. With additions such as Colton Sissons, Nick Paul and Teddy Blueger expected to provide more defensive responsibility, Toronto has attempted to create a deeper and more balanced lineup around captain Auston Matthews.
That could have opened the door for a player such as Skinner to focus primarily on what he does best: creating offense.
Of course, there are legitimate reasons why Toronto passed.
Skinner’s recent production suggests that his best NHL days may be behind him. His inability to secure another NHL opportunity after leaving San Jose also indicates that teams around the league were not convinced he could provide enough value to justify a roster spot.
The Maple Leafs also have plenty of competition for forward positions. Adding another veteran would have meant taking an opportunity away from a younger player or another offseason acquisition.
Still, the argument is that Skinner would have been worth the gamble precisely because the potential reward outweighed the risk. If he failed to regain his scoring form, Toronto could simply move on. If he rediscovered even part of his old offensive ability, however, the Leafs might have found themselves with a valuable depth scorer.
Instead, Skinner will now take his talents to Switzerland. EHC Biel-Bienne announced that he had signed through the end of April 2027, giving the veteran a fresh chapter in his career.
For Toronto, this is hardly a devastating loss. The Maple Leafs have made plenty of moves this offseason and clearly have a different vision for their roster. But considering Skinner’s history as a proven goal scorer, his availability represented an intriguing opportunity.
The biggest question now is whether Skinner still has enough left to make another NHL comeback. If he performs well in Switzerland, teams could potentially revisit that possibility in the future.
For the Maple Leafs, though, that opportunity has passed. Toronto chose not to take the flyer, and the veteran forward is now headed overseas instead.
It may ultimately prove to be the right decision. But if Skinner rediscovers his scoring touch in Switzerland, Toronto could look back and wonder whether a low-cost gamble on a former 30-goal scorer would have been worth taking.
