Emilio Pagán recently expressed strong interest in returning to the Cincinnati Reds. Speaking to reporters, he said he loved his time with the team and would like to “run it back” in 2025. He emphasized his connection with the players and coaching staff, noting that “they know” how much he enjoyed being there. While his comments were hopeful, he also acknowledged the uncertainty of baseball’s business side by saying, “nothing’s guaranteed.”
Pagán’s performance during the 2024 season makes him a valuable bullpen asset. After injuries sidelined some key relievers, he stepped into a high-leverage role and performed well. He appeared in 70 games, posted a 2.88 ERA, and saved 32 games. That level of consistency boosted his market value and made him one of the more reliable relief arms available—if he had chosen to test free agency.
There was early speculation that Pagán would decline his player option and pursue a multi-year deal elsewhere. Several teams were reportedly expected to show interest. However, the Reds made it clear they valued him, with team executives praising his leadership, poise, and ability to handle late-inning pressure. The front office was said to be open to bringing him back, assuming the financials made sense.
Ultimately, Pagán removed the uncertainty by exercising his $8 million player option for the 2025 season. That move guarantees he’ll be back with the Reds for at least one more year. It also showed that Pagán values continuity and comfort, choosing a familiar and supportive clubhouse over gambling on the open market.
This decision stabilizes Cincinnati’s bullpen for next year. With Pagán returning alongside other core arms, the Reds now have a solid late-game group heading into 2025. His presence also gives the team more flexibility in how they manage their young relievers, many of whom were thrust into high-pressure roles earlier than expected in 2024.
From Pagán’s perspective, staying in Cincinnati offers a chance to build on team chemistry and compete for a playoff run. He has publicly praised the culture and energy in the Reds’ clubhouse and seems motivated by more than just salary. His comments suggested unfinished business and a desire to be part of a team that’s building toward something bigger.
While Pagán is now officially back for 2025, questions remain about his long-term future. If he has another strong season, he’ll be positioned to seek a multi-year deal next offseason, either from the Reds or on the open market. That makes 2025 an important year for both Pagán and the organization in terms of planning and performance.
For now, the Reds can take comfort in having a proven veteran anchoring their bullpen. Pagán’s return helps solidify a key part of their roster and signals that both sides are aligned—for at least one more season. Whether the relationship continues beyond that will depend on health, results, and future negotiations.
