Edmonton Journal’s David Staples reported that the Oilers’ offseason produced one of the league’s lowest Goals Above Replacement (GAR) ratings, with minimal gains despite significant cap spending. Analysts noted a disappointing return on investment from veterans and a missed opportunity to build depth.
SB Nation included the Oilers among the biggest losers of 2025 NHL free agency. Their piece pointed to overpaying Evan Bouchard, failing to upgrade goaltending, and continuing to rely on an aging core as reasons for the poor ranking.
The Hockey Writers released a critical breakdown of Edmonton’s worst contracts heading into the 2025–26 season. Darnell Nurse, Adam Henrique, and Trent Frederic were spotlighted as burdens that limited flexibility in free agency and trade opportunities.
Times of India highlighted the firing of goalie coach Dustin Schwartz as a reactionary move. Analysts framed this as a sign the front office was unwilling to confront deeper roster issues after their Stanley Cup Final loss.
Pro Football Network reported that Edmonton had not adequately addressed its goaltending issues during the offseason, citing insider sources who warned that the current netminding tandem remains a liability.
Yahoo Sports Canada contrasted the Panthers’ Stanley Cup-winning investment in Sergei Bobrovsky with Edmonton’s reluctance to spend on elite goaltending, implying the Oilers are betting against a proven formula for playoff success.
The Hockey Writers emphasized that Edmonton’s front office strategy is clashing with the league’s trend toward faster, younger, more affordable talent, which was reflected in their low analytical rankings.
NY Post published a post-mortem on offseason winners and losers, noting the Oilers’ regression in speed and depth. They questioned if Edmonton could stay competitive with a stagnant bottom-six and declining veterans.
Essentially Sports reported on the rising discontent in the fanbase following the team’s offseason strategy. The outlet referenced social media backlash, especially around the departures of young players like Dylan Holloway and Philip Broberg.
Reddit’s r/EdmontonOilers community hosted extended discussions criticizing the offseason. Many fans argued the roster now feels slower, less dynamic, and more prone to playoff fatigue—concerns echoed by analysts and former players alike.
