After a blazing Major League debut on May 18, when Abel threw six shutout innings, struck out nine, allowed no walks, and tied a franchise record for strikeouts in a first outing, much was made of his potential.He followed that up with another strong start, becoming the first pitcher in over a century to throw 5+ innings with no walks and one or fewer runs allowed in his first two MLB appearances.
But just as fast, the narrative shifted. After six starts for the Phillies, Abel’s ERA ballooned to 5.04, and he struggled (especially in his last two outings) with command and effectiveness. The Phillies made the decision to option him back to Triple‑A Lehigh Valley.
In speaking out after his demotion, Abel expressed gratitude and humility. He issued a message on social media thanking fans, family, and the Phillies organization for their support, saying his MLB debut was a “day I’ll never forget.” He also emphasized how the process of self‑reflection has changed his perspective: re‑defining what personal success means, focusing on gradual improvement rather than perfection.
Abel acknowledged that being “forced to move on” from the exhilaration of his debut, and being sent back to the minors so quickly, was an odd transition. But he seems to take it in stride. He’s returning to Triple‑A not as a demoralized player, but as one looking to stabilize, refine, and stay ready for another opportunity.
From the Phillies’ side, the approach seems balanced: they believe in Abel’s talent, composure, and “poise,” but also recognize he must re‑gain consistency. Manager Rob Thomson and the coaching staff have spoken about letting Abel reset — mentally and mechanically — with the hopes that he can return stronger.
Meanwhile, the team’s roster decisions reflect that high‑wire balancing act. Pitchers are being shuffled, positions opened up, and Abel’s future role (rotation vs bullpen, or spot starter) is under active evaluation depending on performance, matchups, and health of other starters.
One thing Abel made clear: he still wants to prove that his debut was not a fluke. That he belongs. That he can carry forward what he showed under bright lights into consistency. And while the road may not be linear, he’s publicly embracing the process — the setbacks, resets, and the work needed to get back to that level.
