The Cardinals are facing a crossroads with their closer, Ryan Helsley, whose contract expires after the season. Projections from Spotrac estimate a hefty $81 million in free agency for Helsley, and analysts believe St. Louis is unlikely to match that figure. With no intention of paying that much, the team is expected to entertain trade offers during the season.
Some insiders and outlets have specifically called for a blockbuster trade. One ClutchPoints writer suggested a deal with Boston could bring back infielder Abraham Toro, a move aimed at shoring up the Cardinals’ infield needs . Meanwhile, speculation is swirling that St. Louis could secure top-flight prospects or even ready-made pitching upgrades from suitors like the Cubs .
According to Newsweek, the consensus is growing that trading Helsley offers clarity and value—his market is hot, and St. Louis has a narrow window to capitalize before he leaves via free agency with nothing in return . The growing sentiment is that even a contending team should consider selling high on an elite reliever like Helsley—especially if the team’s window is closing.
Timing seems particularly critical. With the trade deadline approaching, analysts like Jim Bowden of The Athletic say the move may come down to performance in July. If the Cardinals slip, trading Helsley could become the logical course to bolster their farm system .
All in all, the dominant narrative is this: an $81 million closer on an expiring deal is too valuable to let walk. As the trade deadline approaches, don’t be surprised if St. Louis finally pulls the trigger in what could be one of the season’s most dramatic deadline moves.
